Luis Gonçalves - Blog

Exercises, advises and tips for you.

Why is so difficult for workers to find purpose on their daily job?

http://www.flickr.com/photos/bluespringsfordparts/

http://www.flickr.com/photos/bluespringsfordparts/

Every day we hear how important is to have purpose in our jobs and in our life. Daniel Pink refers in his book “Drive” that in order for us to be truly motivated with our work we need to have a feeling of purpose, mastery and autonomy. Therefore, this post will focus on the purpose component and on the difficulty of finding this purpose at work. What happened in our society that took the purpose away from employees and people? I believe, we can thank the industrial era. Keep reading to find out why.

In the beginning of the twentieth century, the society was much more stable, static and not dynamic. There was not much competition and markets did not move the same speed as they move today. All these factors allowed organisations to centralise decisions and impose top down rules that everyone had to follow. Managers were basically the gate keepers of all decisions and then delegated execution down to the workers. As Thomas Kenneth writes in his book “Intrinsic motivation” : “Managers became the keepers of purpose. Knowing about task purposes and their accomplishment became unnecessary for workers”.

The workers at the end of the line limited themselves to implement the orders that came from upper levels because they did not know anything about the “big picture”. They were mainly workers in assembly lines putting component pieces together and had no vision of the final product. These people were under close supervision by their superiors who enforced compliance using punishments or extrinsic rewards. It was the era of mass production.

So what is the difference to today’s work? And why it is so important for people to have purpose at work?

http://www.flickr.com/photos/healthblog/

http://www.flickr.com/photos/healthblog/

Today’s society is completely different from the society a hundred years ago. The pace of today’s society is unpredictably fast and chaotic. The predictability from other times is not present anymore. Another thing that differs is the type of work. In the industrial era, most of the jobs were in manufacturing, today most of the jobs are in services, making most of today’s workers knowledge workers instead of manual, manufacturing workers.

Organisations must be fast, must innovate and must adapt to their customer needs. Decisions cannot be made in centrally anymore, this would be too slow and not efficient for companies. In order to solve these problems, companies need to trust on their employees allowing them to decide what is the best for the customer and help them to solve their problems. This requires companies to self-empower people and give them freedom to enable them to decide what is the best for the current environment.

Thomas refers in his book: Intrinsic motivation at work: “Organisations need workers to take active responsibility for handling more and more of the uncertainties involved in the accomplishment of their purposes. So organisations have been forced to flatten their hierarchies and push decision making down to workers. Workers are called on to adapt to customers’ needs, simplify and improve organisational processes, coordinate with other workers and teams, and initiate ideas for new products and services.

Today, more and more it is necessary for companies to allow employees to be part of the company’s mission and purpose. When companies allow this, employees will find something with what they identify. They will find the purpose for their work and will help the company succeed. But this is not that simple, most of the management books and universities refer to material that is sometimes outdated. Management literature today points to material that made sense in the industrial era but not today, not anymore. Most of the graduates or people who buy books about this topic are advised to follow old fashioned management tips that do not apply to our modern society anymore. So it is our job to help companies with this difficult task of creating an environment where people feel the purpose in everything they are do at work.

Did you like this post? Are you interested in this topic? Subscribe my newsletter below to get access to weekly news from my side.

Final3dPostCTA

6 thoughts on “Why is so difficult for workers to find purpose on their daily job?”

  1. Szymon Wyrwiak says:

    Good post Luis. I have maybe one question in this context. Now in our new organization we pushing decision to our “team’s” but some people have hard time with it. I have questions like “why our management have don’t have answers? .. they taking money for this”. My arguments like “decision of group may be better than some external decision” and “here is the chance for you” don’t get to some people. Any advice in that matter?

  2. Anko Tijman says:

    So what you’re actually saying is:
    In the industrial era, managers knew more about the bigger picture so they added value to the production workers.
    In the services era, managers know less about the bigger picture because pace is so fast. Their added value lies in other areas than making decisions for the knowledge workers.
    Right?

    My 2 cents for where added value for current managers lies: giving clear guidelines en thresholds, motivating people, empower teams etc - see Management 3.0)

    1. Luis says:

      Hi Anko,

      What I say is the nature of the work in previous times did not require that workers would understand much of the big picture… They just need to put pieces together, they just need to assembly stuff. Nowadays is much more complex than that. We live in a Knowledgeable economy where the nature of work is not at all equal, workers need to use their brain in highly intelectual activities but for that they need to understand as well the big picture.

      But the purpose of this article was just to say that before people were treated as robots and now they cannot, they need to be treated as intelligent human beens this is the only way for people to find their purpose and be able to deliver excellency in what they do.

      About your comment that managers job is motivate I do not agree. :) People cannot be motivated, therefore managers cannot motivate people :) Managers can create systems where people can motivate themselves but no one can motivate people :)

      Cheers,
      Luis

  3. Shikha says:

    Hi Luis,

    Nice post. And absolutly agree with your thoughts we should empower teams to suggest ideas and participate in vision. But these as the younger generation is smarter and intelligent once they start participating they starts behaving differently as though the things cannot move without them. And all this was shown up in attitude, recognition demands and all. How to handle these situations.

    Also, I would like you write an article for us. I am one of the editorial board member of PMI Bangalore India Chapter. Please share your email ID if you finds it ok I will write you seperately on this.

    Thanks,
    Shikha

    1. Luis says:

      Thanks :)

      I will write you :)

  4. People are different, some are content to simply get a task to perform while others want to understand “the big Picture”. There are even those who want to join in and create “the big Picture”. Good leaders will listen to their workers and find the right level for each of them.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

*

Subscribe to our mailing list

* indicates required Email Address * How did you find me Name